What It Means for a Surveyor to Be Impartial
Impartiality means the surveyor cannot take instructions from the owner. They cannot argue for one side, push for a particular outcome or act as an advocate. They examine the facts, assess the proposals, and identify what is needed to protect the adjoining owner’s property while enabling the building owner to proceed with lawful work.
This is different from most other professional roles. Usually, when someone hires a surveyor, that surveyor works directly for them. Under the Party Wall Act, the position is much more formal. The surveyor’s duty overrides any personal preference or request from the appointing owner. This protects the integrity of the process and keeps disputes from escalating.
Why Some Owners Prefer to Appoint Their Own Surveyor
Although the Act allows both owners to agree on a single surveyor, many adjoining owners feel more comfortable appointing their own. This is not because the first surveyor is untrustworthy but because having a separate surveyor can provide reassurance. Each surveyor brings their own perspective and expertise. Together, they make decisions collectively, ensuring transparency and fairness.
When two surveyors are appointed, they select a third surveyor, who rarely becomes involved but remains available to resolve any disagreements. This structure helps maintain balance and ensures neither party feels exposed or unsupported.
Understanding What Party Wall Surveyors Actually Do
Surveyors review the proposed works, assess their likely impact on the neighbouring property, and determine the protections required. They prepare a Party Wall Award that sets out the rights and obligations of each owner. This includes how the work will be carried out, what safeguards must be in place and what happens if something goes wrong.
They also arrange a schedule of condition. This is a detailed record of the adjoining property before work begins. If damage occurs, this provides a clear reference to determine responsibility. Surveyors work to prevent disputes but also put structures in place to resolve them if they arise.
Why Independence Protects Both Owners
Some owners initially feel frustrated when the surveyor does not act solely in their favour. They may wonder why the surveyor will not follow their instructions or push their position more strongly. The answer is that independence protects both sides. If surveyors were influenced by the preferences of the owner who appointed them, the process would break down. Neighbours would not trust each other’s surveyors and disputes would become more adversarial.
By being impartial and working within the Act, surveyors ensure that decisions are fair, reasoned and based on technical understanding rather than personal interest. This reduces tension, supports good neighbourly relationships and helps projects progress safely.
Choosing the Right Surveyor for Party Wall Matters
Because independence is so important, choosing a surveyor should be based on experience and professionalism rather than expectations of advocacy. A good Party Wall Surveyor has a strong understanding of the Act, practical experience with construction and an ability to make balanced decisions. They should communicate clearly, manage expectations and explain their role from the outset.
Owners should select someone they trust to be thorough and fair, not someone they expect to fight on their behalf. When surveyors approach the process correctly, both owners can feel confident in the outcome.
Conclusion
Independent surveyors are essential to the Party Wall process. Their impartiality protects both owners, ensures the works proceed safely and helps maintain good relationships between neighbours. Understanding the surveyor’s role makes the process clearer and helps owners appreciate why independence is central to the Act.
At Harrison Clarke, our surveyors take their statutory responsibilities seriously. We provide clear guidance, balanced decision making and professional support throughout the Party Wall process, ensuring that projects progress smoothly and lawfully.
For more expert advice on surveying and property matters, check out our range of informative videos on our website or YouTube channel. Harrison Clarke Chartered Surveyors is here to guide you every step of the way!
At the time of writing, we have a total of 152 reviews across Trustpilot and Google. We are proud to say that the average rating is over 4.9/5.
